Magpie Magazine, Issue
25, June 2000
Brave New Guitar
Review by Ita Kelly
Nothing is assumed in Frank Kilkelly's
new book Accompanying Irish Music on Guitar except that the reader
is eager to seriously learn something of the accompaniment of Irish traditional
music on guitar. Frank puts it well is his foreword: "Don't
forget," he says; "whatever you're learning, you're learning it so
that you can forget about it when the time comes to have some fun!"
The fun follows the serious practise, and there's a full-page guide given on
'developing a practise routine', so no excuses!
The guitar is a relative newcomer to
Irish traditional music and was much frowned upon when it was first
introduced. Even today there are pockets of opinion about its inclusion in
the 'sacred' tradition. Nevertheless its impact on and sympathy with the
solo instrumentalist cannot be denied. The folk and ballad boom of the
sixties was responsible for guitarists becoming involved with accompaniment of
traditional music although there were early recordings made in the United States
featuring guitarists as early as the 1920s. Donal Lunny once recalled to
me being thrown out of the Pipers Club in Dublin's Church Street because he was
playing guitar. Frank Kilkelly himself tells us in his book that Comhaltas
Ceoltóirí Éireann banned the guitar at one time; "I myself was witness
to this," he says; "when a performance organised by Comhaltas was once
halted while I was removed from the stage!" Times have changed, but
so too has guitar accompaniment, a range of players since the 60s have developed
and augmented accompaniment styles. Frank profiles a number of these from
central figures like Paul Brady and Micheál O Domhnaill to the younger Ian Carr
and Donogh Hennessey. He presents four tunings which progress from
standard tuning to DADGAD tuning by dropping one string at a time.
Suggestions are given for right hand styles suited to each tuning and the
accompanying CD recording allows the student to take a close look at
accompaniment styles used and to practise along with tunes.
"My main idea in putting this book
together was that no-one else had done it. The rhythm part of playing
guitar is the hardest part to teach and is also the part most frequently
omitted. In this tutor each page is self-sufficient. All the
information you need is given to study and play the accompaniment. I wrote
down all the chords from the actual tune recordings, the way I played it and
then any little things that are highlighted or unusual. All the chords you
need to play the set of tunes are there on the same page even though some of
them are on the next page again."
Years of teaching at workshops gave Frank
an insight into the needs of developing guitar players. He is an
accomplished guitarist himself, originally from Castlebar, County Mayo where his
neighbourhood had its share of musicians when he was growing up. He has
played with Alan Kelly, Seán Keane, and Luke Daniels and currently works with
Christy O'Leary. He spent several years in London where he played a lot of
swing jazz. Recently he has teamed up with Seán Lennon and Damien Evans
to play Hot Club Jazz, Grapelli and Django style, it sounds good too. He
is married to fiddle player Eilish O'Connor and is a familiar figure around
Galway, playing or listening! Frank's tutor should be an invaluable asset to
guitar players, be they from a traditional background or not.