Lethality
How to test the lethality offline? The red-shaded headquarters building
beside the Zeppelin hangar at F20 in the "daawf1.trn" terrain
was chosen as a target. Each aircraft was started on the ground and then
taxied to a stop in front of the building. Those inside were given 60 seconds
to evacuate. The gunsight was placed between the first floor windows and
the trigger(s) held down until the building exploded (or not).
The first figure is the ammunition load of each weapon "system",
given in number of rounds. The second figure is the duration of a sustained
burst, until empty, in each weapon "system". The third figure
(Time To...) is the time it took to destroy the building with a sustained
burst.
Figures are given for single and paired weapons in both standard fighter
and "balloon busting" incendiary loads. These figures are then
applied to the aircraft in question.
Tail gunner/observer weapons were not tested as they cannot fire while
on the ground and are marked with the "CNFOG" note.
Bombs were not tested.
Note: The Allied and Axis aircraft have equal lethality in these tests.
The Spandau pairs are equal to the Vickers pairs. The Spandau singles are
equal to the Vickers singles...
Note2: The single .303 Lewis Gun on the SE5a just failed the test by
half a second. Firing both the Lewis and Vickers together gave the SE5a
a score of 19 seconds on the "Armament Standard Load" test.
Armament Standard Load |
|
|
Rounds |
Duration |
Time To... |
1 x .303 Vickers (Spad VII) |
500 |
62s |
37s |
1 x .303 Vickers (F.2B) |
757 |
94s |
37s |
1 x .303 Lewis (SE5a) |
291 |
36.5s |
FAIL |
1 x .303 Lewis (F.2B) |
679 |
85s |
CNFOG |
1 x Spandau (CLII) |
500 |
62s |
37s |
1 x Parabellum (CLII) |
500 |
62s |
CNFOG |
2 x .303 Vickers |
1000 |
62s |
19s |
2 x Spandau |
1000 |
62s |
19s |
Armament Incendiary Load |
|
|
Rounds |
Duration |
Time To... |
1 x .303 Vickers (Spad VII) |
200 |
25s |
FAIL |
1 x .303 Vickers (F.2B) |
300 |
37s |
37s |
1 x .303 Lewis (SE5a) |
097 |
12s |
FAIL |
1 x .303 Lewis (F.2B) |
291 |
36.5s |
CNFOG |
1 x Spandau (CLII) |
200 |
25s |
FAIL |
1 x Parabellum (CLII) |
200 |
25s |
CNFOG |
2 x .303 Vickers |
400 |
25s |
19s |
2 x Spandau |
400 |
25s |
19s |
Armament
Standard Load |
|
Aircraft |
Armament |
Duration |
Time To... |
Fokker DVII |
2 x Spandau |
62s |
19s |
Fokker Dr.1 |
2 x Spandau |
62s |
19s |
Albatros D.Va |
2 x Spandau |
62s |
19s |
Sopwith F.1 Camel |
2 x .303 Vickers |
62s |
19s |
Spad XIII |
2 x .303 Vickers |
62s |
19s |
Bristol F.2B |
1 x .303 Vickers |
94s |
37s |
R.A.F. SE5a |
1 x .303 Vickers |
62s |
37s |
R.A.F. SE5a |
1 x .303 Lewis |
36.5s |
FAIL |
R.A.F. SE5a |
Vickers + Lewis (36.5s) |
62s |
19s |
Halberstadt CLII |
1 x Spandau |
62s |
37s |
Spad VII |
1 x .303 Vickers |
62s |
37s |
Armament
Incendiary Load |
|
Aircraft |
Armament |
Duration |
Time To... |
Fokker DVII |
2 x Spandau |
25s |
19s |
Fokker Dr.1 |
2 x Spandau |
25s |
19s |
Albatros D.Va |
2 x Spandau |
25s |
19s |
Sopwith F.1 Camel |
2 x .303 Vickers |
25s |
19s |
Spad XIII |
2 x .303 Vickers |
25s |
19s |
Bristol F.2B |
1 x .303 Vickers |
37s |
37s |
R.A.F. SE5a |
1 x .303 Vickers |
25s |
FAIL |
R.A.F. SE5a |
1 x .303 Lewis |
12s |
FAIL |
R.A.F. SE5a |
Vickers + Lewis (12s) |
25s |
FAIL |
Halberstadt CLII |
1 x Spandau |
25s |
FAIL |
Spad VII |
1 x .303 Vickers |
25s |
FAIL |
The MGs which the back seaters and the gunners on the Zeppelin use (Parabellum
and Lewis), should have higher rates of fire than the synchronised guns
on the aircraft. The Lewis gun on the SE5a should also have a higher rate
of fire as it is not synchronised. The synchronised Vickers and Spandaus
on the aircraft have the same rate of fire at about 484rpm in DoA. The Spandau
in WWI had a higher rate of fire than the Vickers though. So why are these
different rates not modelled? "Sinbad" wrote some thoughts on
this. They are reprinted below.
"Fire rates given in manuals for machine-guns are theoretical maxima,
based on the assumption that the gun is fired continuously and is not slowed
by the action of any synchronisation gear, i.e. it's not being fired through
the airscrew arc. A typical synchronised gun's theoretical fire rate was
about 200-300 rounds per minute, continuous', rather less in real combat.
The two-seater observer's gun wasn't synchronised, of course, and potential
firing rate was therefore higher.
With the g-forces acting on aircraft-mounted guns and ammunition feeds
and much of the cooling apparatus stripped off those guns for lightness,
it would have been a miracle if a Vickers or Spandau (LMG Model 08, etc)
managed to fire much more than a five-second continuous burst without either
a round jamming in the breech or the feed belt jamming. Ammunition quality
was often quite poor as well, and incendiary ammunition was prone to swell
and jam even more than ball shot. Most scout pilots carried a small rawhide
mallet to knock breech-jammed rounds clear. I read a manual once that reckoned
there were 26 different ways a Vickers could jam, 14 of which the pilot
had some chance of fixing. The stripped Lewis and Parabellums weren't much
better. So pilots and observers fired their guns in short bursts, to conserve
ammunition and to reduce the risk of jamming.
I reckon that iEN have been a bit generous in their fire-rates based
on your findings, probably to promote 'playability' - otherwise, I think
the new firing model is the best feature of v1.3 - it would be even more
realistic if the time taken to change ammo drums on Lewis and Parabellum
guns was simulated by a set time-break, and gun jams were modelled, together
with a similar time-break to represent the time necessary to clear the jam."
Simba. 6th RFC Black Lions. |