Braxtel | Corporate Communications |
Stock Option FAQ |
|
Although stock options were given to most of Braxtel's staff, there was no explanation as to what options were or how the scheme worked. Many questions went unanswered and people were disillusioned with the scheme. As part of my Corporate Services mandate, I was expected to take on the problem and address their concerns. The resulting FAQ managed to address most of them. It took me one day to collate the questions from the staff, about two hours to write the general introduction and two months to get the answers on the scheme out of the solicitors! What are Employee Stock Options? If you own shares, then you own part of the company. If you own Options, then this gives you the opportunity to purchase Shares. Employee stock options give the holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy a certain number of shares of stock at a certain price within a certain time period. Options have a language all their own, but it is not difficult if you have a guide:
Your Braxtel Stock Option Grant Your Braxtel options grant gives you the following information:
There will be other information like what happens if you die and how long you have to exercise vested options if you leave the company or retire.
The following FAQ was prepared with Reddy Charlton and McKnight in response to various questions that have been asked about the Braxtel scheme. They are intended by way of general assistance to employees of Braxtel Communications Limited. These replies are not intended to be a legal interpretation of the Employee Share Option Plan ("the Plan"). Shares have no rights until certificates are issued and recorded on the records of the company or its transfer agents or registrars. Will the company complete this registration? How quickly will this be done? This question relates to Clause 8 of the Option Agreement. The company will issue Share Certificates to Participants who have exercised their options. Reddy Charlton McKnight’s company secretarial department will prepare the Share Certificates upon receiving instructions from Braxtel. How do clauses 13.1 and 13.2 interact? 13.1 seems to give the impression that Options will vest upon takeover, but 13.2 seems to imply that the unexercised ones may be exercised but without making reference to the unvested ones? This question relates to Clause 13.1 and 13.2 of the Plan. Clause 13.1 provides that in the event of a Takeover, all options will be fully vested and exercisable. Clause 13.2 recognises the fact that there may be vested options that have not been exercised, or which have been partially exercised. (This would include options deemed to have accrued under Clause 13.1.) Accordingly, Clause 13.2 provides that such unexercised options will fully vest in the event of a takeover. In summary, any unexercised options, irrespective of when they were granted to the employee, automatically become eligible to be exercised by the employee in the event of a Takeover Will unvested shares vest upon an IPO. Are they subject to 13.1 and 13.2? Would you have to exercise straight away. Would there be a holding period where you would be barred from selling after an IPO? The question of "unvested shares vesting" does not arise because any shares acquired or granted pursuant to an option under the Plan will be fully vested. It is the options themselves that accrue, or vest if you like. The documentation does not provide for automatic accrual of options in the event of an IPO (unless the IPO also constitutes a Takeover). The options will continue to be held in the public company under the terms as they would have been held in the private company. Again, there is no provision for a holding period where a Participant who has exercised his option would be barred from selling his shares after an IPO. As the documentation provides for the options accruing over a period of time, the limitation on the Participant would be that he would only be able to exercise options when the relevant time had passed. Once that Participant has exercised his option and acquired shares, then the only limitations on disposal of shares will apply and these are governed by the Articles of Association (that is, the new IPO Articles of Association, which will almost certainly have restrictions on how soon and how quickly an employee may sell his/her shares) What would happen in the event of a takeover by a member who wished to purchase the whole company? Would shares vest? There is no provision for automatic accrual of options in the event of an existing member at the date of the Plan acquiring the whole of the capital of the company. Clause 13 of the Plan deals with the situation where a third party takes over the company. How could somebody become a shareholder if they are not already a member of the company? A person who is not already a member of the company can become a member/shareholder by acquiring shares in the company. Outside parties, such as a new investor, can acquire shares in accordance with the Articles. Who sets the value of the company and how often can it be changed? The value of the Company is set by Board whenever it issues an Option Agreement. The board decides how often it can be changed: it is probable that a valuation would take place after an investment How often can you exercise Options? Are there conditions on a minimum number to be exercised at a time? Under the terms of the Option Agreement, the options accrue monthly over a three-year period (see Clause 3). If, for example, a Participant is granted options over 360 shares, then after 1 month of the Option Agreement, the Participant would be entitled to acquire 10 shares (i.e. 1/36th of 360). After 1 year, the Participant would be entitled to acquire 120 shares (ie 1/3rd of 360). There is no limit on the number of times that the options can be exercised, provided that the options have accrued. There is no minimum number of options that must be exercised at a time. What is a share currently worth? At the time of writing (February 2001) the option price is IR£0.3775 for European employees and US$0.462 for American employees. Would the payment of income tax relating to the exercise of options be done through the company or would this be something the participant would have to sort out? The company is not responsible for collecting the income tax. Thus, when exercising one’s options, the participant needs to pay the company the exercise amount, and needs to make his/her own arrangement to pay the required income tax. Does the company have any subsidiaries? Are they wholly owned. Yes, Digicommcare Limited. It is wholly owned. This is a patent-holding company and does not trade. The clause on Suspension of Exercisability, when could it be foreseen that this would be used? The purpose of this clause is to ensure that the terms of the Option Plan will not conflict with the laws of the land. What we foresee is a situation where the purchase of shares by a Participant would require certain fiscal or regulatory approvals in a certain jurisdiction (or in a particular state, in the case of U.S. employees). Having exercised an option and it being fully registered to whom can this be sold and under what conditions, or how can value be realized from it? A Participant, having exercised an option and acquired shares in the company, will be bound by the Articles of Association if they wish to sell their shares in the company. (See also reply to Question 12). Essentially, the shares must be offered to existing shareholders first. Where are the methods of purchasing and selling shares set out? The Articles of Association provide for the procedure where a shareholder wishes to sell shares in the company. With regard to the method of purchasing shares, in the context of the Plan, the procedure whereby Participants can acquire shares is as set out in the Plan and/or Option Agreement. What are the conditions on selling shares and whom can they be sold to? Unless shares are being transferred to a spouse or child of the employee, shares cannot be transferred without first being offered for sale to existing shareholders. How does vesting work? The easiest way to explain how the options accrue is by way of example: Let us say that a Participant is granted options over 360 shares in the company. In accordance with the Option Agreement, these shares will vest monthly over a 3-year period. At the end of the first month, the Participant will be entitled to acquire 1/36th of 360 shares, i.e. 10 shares. Similarly at the end of the second month, a Participant would entitled to acquire a further 10 shares. This will continue month by month until the end of the 3-year period, at which stage the options will be fully accrued and exercisable. A Participant may chose to acquire – that is, buy – shares at any time, provided of course that the options have accrued. For example, a Participant might decide to acquire shares at the end of the first month, but then not acquire any further shares for a further 6 months. At the end of that subsequent 6 month period, the Participant will be entitled to acquire a further 60 shares There may be confusion as some Participants will be familiar with the concept of unvested shares. However, in the case of the Plan, it is the options that "vest", or more properly "accrue". Once an option has accrued, any shares bought on foot of the option will be fully vested. Can you sell an unexercised option? A Participant cannot sell unexercised options. In accordance with Clause 4 of the Option Agreement, options are exercisable only by Participants, or in the event of the Participant’s death by the Participant’s personal representative. How much notice is needed to exercise an option? Who is this request made to? How long will it take to get the option exercised? The procedure for exercising options is detailed in Clause 5 of the Option Agreement. There is no set period of notice that must be given. It is sufficient for the Participant to give written notice to the Company Secretary at which stage the company will immediately initiate the process of issuing a share certificate to the Participant in respect of those shares, provided of course that the Participant has provided full payment to the company. Can you exercise an option during your month’s notice or must you exercise before giving notice. Does that month count towards vesting. An employee is still an employee of the company during their period of notice. They may still exercise options during their period of notice, but once they have ceased to be an employee of the company, at the end of that notice period, any unexercised options shall expire in accordance with Clause 10 of the Plan. What happens if a person leaves before the 36-month vesting period is up, and how would they go about purchasing options prior to leaving? As mentioned earlier, the option accrues evenly over a month-by-month basis over 36 months. A Participant is entitled, prior to leaving the company, to exercise options that have accrued. Once their employment with the company has ceased, other than in the event of death, mental incapacity, redundancy and disability, all options lapse When does the 36 month period begin? The 36-month period begins on the date that the Option Agreement is signed by the company and the Participant. Are all shares valued at the same o/p The Company has at its discretion the opportunity to insert different option prices into individual Option Agreements. At the time of writing (February 2001) the option price is IR£0.3775 for European employees and US$0.462 for American employees. When can we buy shares / options Shares can be acquired pursuant to an option once the option has accrued. What does it mean that in a take-over that it’s at board discretion if we get full value shares? This question would seem to relate to Clauses 13.2 and 13.3 of the Plan. (See also reply to Question 2). Clause 13.2 allows the Board to call on a Participant holding options under the Plan to exercise unexercised options in relation to the whole or a portion of the shares to which their options relate. The Board has discretion to call on the Participant to exercise unexercised options within a certain period of time, subject to any other conditions or limitations as the board may, at its discretion, determine with a view to ensuring that options held by Participants are exercised at a reasonable date prior to the completion of the takeover. Clause 13.2 is intended to ensure that options are exercised in sufficient time before the completion of the takeover. If a Participant has not exercised options prior to the takeover, the Participant’s options lapse but the Participant will be compensated in accordance with Clause 13.3. The form of compensation will consist of (a) the grant of options in respect of shares in another company, or (b) payment in cash, or (c) partly (a) and partly (b). The Board acting in good faith will have discretion in determining the form of compensation. What are the tax implications? Normally, when an employee exercises a share option, a charge to income tax will arise based on the excess of the value of the shares over the option price. The tax charge arises at the time of exercise even where the employee might actually retain the shares. However, the provisions contained in the Finance bill 2001 now offer favourable tax treatment for options granted under a Revenue approved share option scheme. Accompanying this FAQ is a briefing from PriceWaterhouseCoopers and it covers the tax implications in greater detail. In summary, options granted through an approved scheme will not be liable to income tax on grant or exercise provided the shares acquired on foot of the option are not sold before the third anniversary of grant. When sold after this period, a charge to CGT will arise on the excess of the net sale proceeds over the actual option price. This gain will be liable to CGT, currently 20%. An employee’s IR£1000 annual CGT exemption can be offset against the gain. What happens to your shares upon resigning from the company? The Articles of Association fully describe what happens to shares when an employee resigns from the company. When an Employee Member resigns, they will be deemed to have given a Transfer Notice to the Board indicating that they desire to transfer the "Compulsory Transfer Shares" at the Compulsory Transfer Price. The Compulsory Transfer Price is the fair value of such a share as determined by the auditors (in accordance with various articles). If the company wants the departing employee to retain their shares (regardless whether these were bought under an option agreement or given as part of a bonus), it must apply for a Waiver to the nominated directors. Where are the Articles of Association and who can have a copy? The Articles of Association of Braxtel Communications Limited is a document of public record. Any shareholder in the company is entitled to a full copy. Braxtel will provide each employee members with a copy of Articles of Association. Employees should address any such request to Braxtel’s solicitors, Ready, Charlton and McKnight Should the shareholders be issued with accounts for the year end? Auditors’ accounts will be presented at the annual AGM, which each shareholder is entitled to attend, and each shareholder will be entitled to a copy. Will the solicitors provide professional indemnity against loss due to conflict between ESOP and the Articles of Association? Clause 21 of the Plan clearly indicates that in the event of any conflict between the provisions of the Plan and the Articles of Association, the Articles shall prevail. There is no question of the company’s solicitor providing professional indemnity against any supposed loss suffered by Participants due to conflict between the Plan and the Articles. Employees should take their own legal advice - the company’s solicitors act for the company, not for the Participants. |
2001 - John Rowley - All rights reserved. |